Designing with Light
|
Specialty Sources
PART ART, PART INDUSTRY
|
| Though incandescents, fluorescents, and halogen bulbs are the workhorses of home lighting, several other light sources are gaining a foothold, too. Some, like neon and HID, have been around for a while; others, notably fiber optics, are up-and-coming stars. Look for improved, updated versions of all these sources in the coming years. |
Neon
This zoomy light source, bringing to mind 1950s casino and bar signs, is generated when electricity passes through a gas. Neon gas, to be specific, glows orange-red (other gases give off a variety of colors). Neon’s low light output makes it undesirable as a functional light source, but it can be bent into all sorts of decorative, sculptural shapes.
Requiring a 24-volt transformer, neon fixtures can be expensive to buy, though they don’t use much energy and may last for years. Newer transformers have reduced the sometimes objectionable buzz emitted from older neon sources.
Neon for home lighting is sold primarily as freestanding pieces though individual artisans or lighting showrooms. |
Cold Cathode
Long-lasting cold cathode shines in contoured, confined quarters
where other sources fear to tread. Its typical white light
is brighter than neon, making it more useful for ambient lighting,
and its custom-shaping capability offers decorative flourish.
Cold cathode is often the high-end light of choice for indirect,
architectural use and for inaccessible coves and valances
where changing shorter-lived bulbs or tubes presents a major
challenge. Think of it as fluorescent that can follow a curve.
Like neon, cold cathode is available from lighting showrooms
and lighting designers.
|
Fiber Optics
Really a vehicle rather than a light source, fiber optics carry a light or other media (such as data signals) as if through a tunnel. Put a light source such as halogen or metal halide at one end, and the glass or plastic fiber tubing will beam it efficiently toward the other end.
End-lit fiber optics shine bright light out the open end of opaque fiber cable; edge-lit versions shine all the way along transparent tubing. On one hand, fiber optics function as a decorative alternative to neon or cold cathode, following contoured shapes at will. Unlike neon or cold cathode, however, fiber optics will transmit any color, by shining the light through colored filters.
Fiber optics excel in several other ways, too: the end-lit fiber cable can go places ordinary electrical cable can’t, and it can be covered over; and because there’s no electrical current passing through to use around water, in-doors and out.
On the down side, fiber optics are still quite expensive, and they can be tricky to connect.
|
| |
| High-Intensity Discharge (HID)
HID bulbs produce a lot
of light while using a relatively small amount of power. You’ve
seen them, but it’s probably been in street lighting
or public places. Requiring special fixtures and ballasts,
these largish lights may take up to 7 minutes to ignite once
switched on. The color emitted by most HID bulbs ranges from
mildly to extremely unflattering, metal halide is a noticeable
exception.
Mercury Vapor Light
Mercury vapor light is produced by a bulb-within-a-bulb shaped
much like an oversize A-bulb. Fixtures are available for garden
and security lighting. While color rendering is a ghoulish
blue-green, it’s usually acceptable for outdoor uses.
High-Pressure Sodium
High-pressure sodium, a distinctively orangish source, is
the number one choice for street lighting. It’s also
used indoors commercially and industrially. Like mercury vapor,
high-pressure sodium bulbs require a special ballast and fixture.
Low–Pressure Sodium
Low-pressure sodium sports a u-shaped tube within a larger
bulb. An even duller orange than its high-pressure counterpart,
low-pressure sodium is even more efficient. Thus it’s
used extensively for highway and security lighting.
|

Metal Halide
Metal halide is the HID source most likely to come in from
the cold in coming years. Why? Its color temperature is far
more pleasant than most HIDs, ranging from 3,000 degrees K
to 4,000 degrees K. The technology is similar to mercury vapor
but almost twice as efficient.
In addition, metal halide bulbs can be made smaller than
other HID sources, allowing for more attractive fixtures.
While it’s used primarily for outdoor security lighting,
metal halide is now also available in table lamp wattages
with integral ballasts.
|
| BULB COMPARISONS AT A GLANCE |
| INCANDESCENT |
|
Description |
Common
Wattages |
Efficiency
(Lumens per watt) |
Color
Temperature(K) |
Bulb Life
(hours) |
| A-bulb |
|
Familiar pear shape; frosted or clear. |
15 to 250 |
13.5 to 18.5 |
2,800 |
750 to 2,500 |
| Three-way |
 |
A-bulb shape; frosted; two filaments provide three light levels |
30/70/100 to 100/200/300 |
10 to 15 |
2,800 |
1,000 to 1,600 |
| T-Tubular |
 |
Tube-shaped, from 5" long. Frosted or clear |
15 to 40 |
7.5 to 10 |
2,800 |
1,000 to 1,5000 |
| R-Reflector |
 |
White or silvered coating directs light out end of funnel- shaped bulb. |
30 to 120 |
8 to 12.5 |
2,800 |
1,000 to 2,000 |
| Silvered bowl |
 |
Same shape as A-bulb, with silvered cap to cut glare and produce indirect light. |
25 to 60 |
8 |
2,700 to 3,000 |
1,000 |
| G-Globe |
 |
Ball-shaped bulb, 2" to 6" in diameter; frosted or clear. |
25 to 100 |
6 to 12 |
2,800 |
1,500 to 2,500 |
Flame-shaped
(candle) |
 |
Decorative; specially coated; frosted or clear. |
15 to 60 |
8 to 11 |
2,800 |
1,500 |
| FLUORESCENT |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Tube |
 |
Tube-shaped, 5" to 96" long. Needs special fixture and ballast. |
8 to 95 |
35 to 48 |
2,700 to 6,300 |
7,500 to 20,000 |
| PL-Compact tube |
 |
U-shaped with base; 5 1/4" to 7 1/2" long. |
7 to 27 |
70 to 78 |
2,700 to 6,300 |
9,000 to 10,000 |
| Circline |
 |
Circular, 6" to 16" in diameter; may replace A-bulbs or require special fixtures. |
22 to 40 |
50 to 66 |
2,700 to 4,200 |
12,000 |
| Compact bulb |
 |
Many shapes and sizes, replacing incandescent bulbs without needing special sockets. |
11 to 42 |
41 to 58 |
2,700 to 6,300 |
9.000 to 10,000 |
| QUARTZ HALOGEN |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Low-voltage MR-16
(mini-reflector) |
 |
Tiny (2" diameter) projector bulb; gives small circle of light from a distance. |
20 to 75 |
14 to 19 |
2,925 to 3,050 |
2,000 to 4,000 |
PAR-Parabolic
aluminized reflector |
 |
Similar to auto headlamps; special shape and coating project light and control beam. |
50 to 120 |
8 to 13 |
3,050 |
2,000 to 6,000 |
| Specialty |
 |
Small, clear bulb with consistently high light output, used in halogen fixtures only. |
50 to 500 |
18 to 22 |
3,050 |
2,000 |
| HIGH-INTENSITY DISCHARGE(HID) |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Mercury vapor |
 |
Bulb-within-a-bulb, shaped like an oversize A-bulb; needs special ballast. |
100 to 250 |
63 |
3,300 to 3,900 |
16,000 to 24,000 |
| Metal halide |
 |
Almost twice as efficient as old mercury vapor, needs special ballast and fixture. |
175 to 400 |
71 to 100 |
3,700 to 4,00 |
7,500 to 20,000 |
| High-pressure sodium |
 |
Orange-hued light; needs special ballast and fixture. |
50 to 400 |
64 to 95 |
2,100 |
16,000 to 24,000 |
|
|
|
|